I once was appointed to a church where the choir had quit. You laugh. And I did to. I did so to keep from crying on the Monday morning after my first Sunday of struggling through a service with an empty choir loft, a divided church and recently hired Russian pianist who had taught herself how to play the organ and played every good ole Methodist hymn like a Tchaikovsky ballet. That first Sunday we sang as our opening hymn the old Methodist standard, Come Thou Fount of Every Blessing, and by the time we were done, the fount and the blessings had been had been drained off into Swan Lake. We concluded the service with Marching to Zion. After all, everybody can sing Marching to Zion, right? Well, not to the tempo of the Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairy. The entire service was like a pirated version of The Nutcracker and I was the Mouse King who had somehow survived getting stabbed near the end of act one. I kept replaying over and over the conversation I had with the Superintendent who had failed to mention anything to me about the previous minister’s four year war with the previous choir director. He just kept saying how this church needed effective leadership and how confident he was in my abilities to have an effective ministry there.
I mean the choir had quit…
They had quit!!!
They had gotten up in the middle of a service, left their robes in their pews and
walked out the door never to sing again!!!!!!!
And here I was trying to lead worship with an empty choir loft and the daughter of Boris Yeltsin’s third cousin twice removed at the keyboard. Filled with tidings of comfort and joy I was not. Now to some of you, this may seem like an insignificant detail easily overlooked and even more easily overcome. After all, it’s just a choir. It’s just singing a few hymns. You still have the word. You still have the sacraments. You can still pray. You can still preach. Well, this is all true. But, over the course of my ministry, I have learned how important the choir is to worship and how central worship is to being the church. We Protestants are by nature singing people, we Methodists, especially so. Some of our best theology is contained in our hymns. Some of our best Christian education and spiritual formation is done through teaching and learning hymns and songs of praise. And with apologies to our Quaker brothers and sisters, I believe that I am on solid ground when I say that the church is never more truly the church than when our voices are joined together in an act of corporate worship, singing together our praises to God, giving witness to the work of the Spirit in our lives. Saint Augustine said it best, “Those who sing once, pray twice.”
Well, by October of that first year, we were without an accompanist once again and facing Advent and Christmas without a choir. We were in the midst of the arduous task of trying to find an organist/choirmaster, only to discover that they were few to be found. We were just about to give up hope when we received a phone call the Director of Music at another church in town. He had a man singing in his choir who might be just what we were looking for. He was a trained organist, a talented musician and looking for a church job. Now, have you ever forgotten to ask the question? I forgot to ask the question. I forgot to ask why such a gifted and talented musician was currently unemployed? Pastoral words of advice…don’t forget to ask the question.
We met. He was a very talented and talkative musician. He knew his way around the organ and he was very interested in the job. He especially liked the fact that the organ in this church had dual capabilities as a pipe organ and as a digital instrument. More about that later. I had some reservations about him, but when he met with the search committee, all they could think about was being able possibly to have a choir on Christmas Eve. He was hired on the spot and word began to spread through the congregation and the community that there would indeed be a Christmas Eve Choir.
The first hint of trouble on the horizon was when I saw the announcement for the bulletin on his first Sunday. It read: Choir members needed for Christmas Eve Choir. Must be able to both sing and read music. Auditions begin on Wednesday night. Thankfully, I saw this before the bulletin went to print. I immediately got him on the phone and helped him to rewrite his announcement. When it went to print, it read: Join our Christmas Eve Choir. Open Auditions. Everyone Invited.
People responded. In fact, several of the former choir members who had abruptly walked out walked back in just as abruptly. There was Dorothy (name changed), one of the matriarchs of the church, whose piety masked her pretentiousness. There was James (name also changed), who had a marvelous tenor voice, but never felt fully appreciated by his family or his church. And then there was Gerald (again, name changed), whose presence added more tension than talent. But, after all, we did say open auditions. Practices were well attended. All voice parts were covered. Every pitch was present. Talent was slim, but spirits were high. Choir robes were sent out to be dry-cleaned. It began to look like we would have a choir on Christmas Eve after all.
When we sat down to go over the service the week prior to Christmas, I knew we were in trouble. The service was to be a modified Service of Lessons and Carols ending with candle lighting. Because of the placement of the organ, the director could not direct from the organ. But, because of the digital capabilities of the organ, the music could be played and the organ could digitally record itself and play what it had recorded with the flip of a switch and a push of a button. It was the actual organ. It sounded just like an organist was sitting at the bench. It was technologically sophisticated, unique and for some, cutting edge. But for me, it was a disaster waiting to happen. What if it didn’t work? What if a power surge made the night truly a silent night? What if the remote failed? What if it all fell apart? What if the wrong switch was flipped or the wrong button pushed? I was assured that all would go as planned. I had my doubts.
Christmas Eve arrived. The church was packed. Anticipation was high. The choir loft filled up. The acolytes entered. The service began.
O come, all ye faithful, joyful and triumphant, O come ye, O come ye to Bethlehem.
Come and behold him, born the king of angels, O come let us adore him, Christ the Lord.
We made it through the first hymn, and then through the first anthem. We sang a few more carols and we listened as the lessons were read. I was just about to believe that we could actually pull this off, when my worst fears were realized. The final anthem before we were to light candles and sing Silent Night fell apart. Someone pushed the wrong button and the organ took on a life of its own. It began to play songs that were not even in the hymnal. I will never forget the look on the choir director’s face and the speed with which he got from the choir loft to the organ bench. I never knew you could move that fast in organ shoes. He pushed buttons, pulled out stops and did his best to redeem the situation. But to no avail. The congregation sat there stunned. Members of the choir dropped their heads in shame. And the pastor watched his greatest fears unfold right before his very eyes. It was a liturgical disaster of the utmost proportion.
I let it go on until the pain was almost unbearable and until I had finished writing out the ad for the new organist/choir director. I stood up and invited the ushers to come forward and instructed them to be prepared to carry the light throughout the congregation. We would be singing Silent Night with piano accompaniment to conclude the service. Please stand. And we stood. The light began to make its way from the Christ Candle throughout the congregation and we began to sing, Silent Night, Holy Night, all is calm and all is bright.
It was almost painful to sing the words. Calm, tender and mild in no way described this night. Sleep in heavenly peace I would not. But something happened as we began to sing the second verse. One of the men began to sing a bit louder than the rest of the choir. In fact, he was singing louder than the rest of the congregation. And not on key. Not even in the ballpark. I adjusted my stance so I could try and determine who it was. And as fate would have it, it was Gerald. Gerald was not the choir member you wanted to feel inspired, especially not on Christmas Eve. Not only could Gerald not hold a tune in a bucket, Gerald could not find a note if it was gift wrapped with his name printed on it in all capital letters. Oh how I regretted those open auditions. We quaked along with the shepherds as Gerald gained confidence with each measure. His voice stood out and was noticed by all. But Gerald didn’t care who was listening. Though off key and even further off pitch, Gerald sang his praises to the God of open auditions and we all followed his lead. This mere shepherd had somehow heard the real message of Christmas through all the liturgical and technological chaos of the evening. Gerald sang in the choir not because of his talent, but in spite of it. And he knew, better than anyone else, that he would have not been there that night but for the fact that there had been open auditions. It was a moment of redemption for him and for us all. That night, in spite of all that happened, God chose the one with the least talent and the biggest heart to remind us all that God chooses to dwell in us not for what we have to offer, but rather, because all we have to offer is ourselves.
At Christmas, the God of open auditions comes among us again, asking only for hearts that are open and voices that are willing to join in the heavenly chorus and proclaim to the entire world that because of what happened on that first Christmas long ago, things can be different. Light can shine into the dark places of our lives. Hope can be reborn in the stables of our souls. Forgiveness can find that there is indeed room to dwell. Love can heal the broken places and comfort the broken hearted. Redemption can be found by both the deserving and the undeserving. And peace, lasting peace can become not just a tune we hum once a year, but rather a canticle for what can be each day of our lives when God in Christ dwells within us. Auditions are open. Who among us is willing to join in and sing?












Serendipity is usually defined as unexpectedly discovering something fortunate or helpful, especially when looking for or expecting something entirely unrelated.